Mr Freeway:

Gotta go with Brady for right now.

 

it's 4th and 13. down 4pts on the 20yd line.

00:06 secs on the clock in the superbowl

who do you want under center?

I say right now because of numbers.

 

 

Romo to Witten 

waredatriplets:

Mr Freeway:

Gotta go with Brady for right now.

 

it's 4th and 13. down 4pts on the 20yd line.

00:06 secs on the clock in the superbowl

who do you want under center?

I say right now because of numbers.

 

 

Romo to Witten 

Thank you. And when the pocket breaks down, i want the man that doesn't panic under pressure. Romo is right up there with talent/skill. It's that extra dimension he brings that puts him over.

isrealycowboy:

so what is your point?  we know romo is younger then brady and peyton, and is on his first year as a starter. give him time, he will be better then both of them! he plays much better on his first year, then they have on theirs!

My point is that the question was "Who is the Best QB in the NFL?" Romo may, as you say, one day prove to be their equal or better, but alas, that was not the question.

You guys had me ballin here. Obviously Brady is having the better season. Who's the best QB right now this season

1. Brady

2. Romo

3. Manning

I would love to see the results posted on the Cheats forums.

Manning is more consistant than any of them, and can still make passes count evebn when his best WR's are injured. Brady had to bring in better receivers to make HIM good. And while Romo is breaking records left and right, the true measure of a QB is consistancy.Romo has only had a little over a full year combined to show us how good he is. In time, and with continued consistant play, Romo will surpass both Brady AND Manning!

bwright:

Manning is more consistant than any of them, and can still make passes count evebn when his best WR's are injured. Brady had to bring in better receivers to make HIM good. And while Romo is breaking records left and right, the true measure of a QB is consistancy.Romo has only had a little over a full year combined to show us how good he is. In time, and with continued consistant play, Romo will surpass both Brady AND Manning!

Wow I hope so!!! Getting me excited for years to come.

Romo is immune to pressure.

 

 

I would, however, pick Brady because he gets as many tries as he needs on 4th down 

A lot of you guys are just picking the guy that's having a better year.  If Manning had Brady's weapons, you'd be picking Manning.  Manning was doing fine until Harrison went down.  Each of the three has his strengths and weaknesses and if Romo continues w/ his stellar play he will be right up there w/ both.  However, Manning is still overall the best right now.  You have to factor in the team before you make a decision. 

manning is a crappy quarterback.. hate him soooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo much.. i also despise the team he plays for... manning is just a retarded marketing machine for the nfl... the stupid good hearted southern boy...hate him...

 

anyways... it goes Brady, he's won 3 superbowls already... is putting up fantastic numbers this year... then Romo.. romo is my fav quarterback of all time... but brady is just having a notch up year... but romo is every way possible better than manning.. so what.. there's injuries to their team big effing whoop... we've missed terry glenn the whole year and romo is just better at dealing with things such as pressure and stuff... romo will be the best quarter in a year at the latest... and i hate the stupid saying "oh the AFC is a much better conference than the NFC" so what? Dallas is right up there with new england and a thousand times better than indy..

brady has had lots of video tapes to help him win superbowls, so Romo is my choice.

I do not support the faketriots in any way.

AHolmes:

 It's Brady, but on a Cowboys board, is there any doubt Romo is going to come out ahead in this poll?

I am not being biased, I really think Romo is the better quarterback.  Why you ask?  Because look at the hand he was dealt, he took TUNA salad and made Filet Mignon.

RomoRomo9:

brady has had lots of video tapes to help him win superbowls, so Romo is my choice.

I do not support the faketriots in any way.

Enough said.

Romo is by far the best on the move and if the pocket collapses. Ill give him that, and the fact he can keep plays alive. He is a young farve if i have to make a comparison.

 

Brady has a stacked team in moss/welker/stallworth. honestly even culpepper could throw the ball and moss could catch it, Moss is talented but I hate his attitude he took with the raiders, its really just pathetic.

Peyton has an amazing TALENT in reading D's. Hes a film freak and can tear up a D. and hes been playing without a lot of talent he should have had this year in tarik and harrison. 

 

 

The best pocket passer in the league is Peyton Manning.

The best gun slinger in the league is Tony Romo.

The best running quarterback in the league is Vince Young.

 

I picked Romo but I think Romo and Manning are the top QBs and then you have Brady at number 3. I honestly dont think he is really that amazing. He is really good but he is no Romo or Manning. If Romo or Manning where under center for the Pats with Moss running straight down the field, they would be even better. I am very thankful Romo is a Cowboy!!