America's Team.
First and foremost, the rules of both forums are clearn, and that is that you do not address a problem with a moderator or moderators in the public forums.
Questions or concerns about a staff member or their actions needs to be addressed via a private message. Public criticism of the staff, any of it's members, or anyone else for that matter, will not be tolerated under any circumstances.
Secondly, the Roy thread and other threads that were created by members were not official threads at first. We the staff decided to make them official threads.
The Official Thread rules on the other forum, if they are not clear to you I will explain. The rules state that members not start threads with the title "Official". Does that mean the thread cannot turn into an official thread? No. It means the "title" can only be changed by a Moderator if requested by the member and all Moderators agree.